accountabilitybloke (old blog)

we have moved to mjdubnick.dubnick.net/blog

Moving targets and bridge crossings….

Writing a paper focused on various explanations of the financial crisis is one of those “aiming at a moving target” experiences. The Planet Money folks at NPR are making matters worse with their terrific segments (for the various NPR news shows and This American Life. In a move that is a bit strange, last Friday they offered some “outtake” material (listen here – first 17:20 of podcast) from the TAL show that would not air until Sunday — but fortunately I did not get to those until after hearing the Watchmen podcast. Put the two together in Sunday-Friday sequence and you really have a terrific bit of informative reporting….

Also included in the Friday show was a piece (starting at about 17:20) about an “oath” taken by Harvard MBA grads last week (also here) — an oath that would (if taken seriously) commit the takers to a carerr of “creating social value” in addition to the value they create for corporate share/stakeholders. This sounded awfully familiar, since one of the most notable themes of Mark Moore and his colleagues at the JFK School “down the road” (actually, across the bridge) from HBS is teaching their public administration/affairs folks to “create public value”( also here). Sure enough, the student interviewed as part of the Planet Money piece was actually a student at JFK as well…..

June 11th, 2009 Posted by | accountabilitybloke | no comments

Of executioners and chimps….

It has now been a few days since “catching” this damn head cold, and each night is proving more difficult — so I plug in my iPod and lay there in the dark wheezing and listening to the backlog of podcasts (the wheeze is very musical — I find myself stopping the podcast to figure out whether it is me or some background music…)

It is now around 6AM and having just listened to (among other things) this week’s podcast of This American Life, I am compelled to post one of my intermittent blogs. The episode is titled “Human Resources” and it is (as Ira Glass organizes it) in three acts (with a nice Prologue). Each is (as is usual with this show) a small bit of genius….

The Prologue is about someone whose job was to fire folks — an HR professional who Glass calls “the executioner”. This (along with Act One) will certainly become part of my case in MPA courses (I really do not like to teach the HR portion — but this stuff makes it interesting). Since he has himself has been “executed” (more than likely through outsourcing), the conversation is a bit more interesting. What is fascinating to me is the management of words during the firing process — not so much to make someone feel positive about what is happening to them, but to make them acquiesce (shades of Murray Edelman).

Act One is about the “Rubber Room” (actually rooms) used by the New York City Department of Education for purposes of “reassigning” teachers determined (for a variety of reasons) to be problems at their former location. Put in perspective (only one percent of NYC teacher, and some are there for short periods, others for long periods), the rubber room arrangement seems very bureuacratically rationale. In that respect it is a great condensed case study of what Ralph Hummel describes in his The Bureaucratic Experience — and so still another instructional resource has fallen into my lap (but oh, those poor people….). (There is a documentary in the works on this…)

Act Two about “The Plan” seems a bit out of place among the segments (even more so than the Chimps segment that follows). It is, however, a terrific example of conspiracy theory thinking which many folks rely on when trying to make sense of the political world. I use the idea of “making sense” in a number of courses — from American government (have even integrated the idea in our textbook) to basic PA and organization theory. This is a keeper….

Finally, Act 3 — the Chimp segment — is a bit weird at first blush, but it can serve a number of purposes. There is, of course, the ethical dimension about our treatment of non-human species (see Nussbaum’s Frontiers of Justice), but there is also the interesting aspect of implementing a formal public policy — they refer to it as the Clinton Chimp Act. The intersection of ethics and policy are interesting enough, but then you add in the observations of a New York Times reporter (who is the main source in the segment), and you have the final reason why listeing to TAL is so valuable…..

Enough — I feel a chill coming on — literally…

March 9th, 2009 Posted by | accountabilitybloke | no comments

MSNBC as the new Fox News….

In our household we’ve developed a taste for MSNBC as the anti-Fox News cable station, but the folks there seem to be engage in a left-leaning emulation of Fox News rather than providing an alternative model. Put bluntly, they seem wiling to do anything to keep those growing numbers up, even if it involves manipulation of the storyline to stir the juices….

Case in point is the obvious push of the MSNBC crew to label Obama as just another politician who is heading to the right and away from some imagined position on the left. Rachel Maddow [who, despite this evening’s performance, deserves a regular spot of her own (hear her interview on On The Media)], sat in for Keith Olbermann tonight and was clearly engaged in spinning the current Arianna Huffington argument that Obama is abandoning his established positions. Much of this can be seen as an effort by the MSNBC folks to offset its growing image as the anti-Bush, pro-Obama station (which it certainly deserves), while at the same time maintaining its credibility among the blogging left headed by Huffington, Kos and company. Not that there is anything wrong with that…. But perhaps they are carrying this a bit too far.

July 2nd, 2008 Posted by | accountabilitybloke | no comments